Debates ยท II. The King's Permission
When was the Sushruta Samhita composed? disputed
Positions
-
A traditional early date
Tradition and popular histories place Sushruta around 600 BC and call him the father of surgery.
Sources- Didusch Museum newsletter: Breaking the Stone Age (2025) Museum or society
-
A text compiled over centuries
The film treats the surviving Samhita as a layered work built up over many centuries, with no single date of composition. The Didusch Museum newsletter frames it as spanning roughly 600 BCE to 600 AD.
Sources- Didusch Museum newsletter: Breaking the Stone Age (2025) Museum or society
Evidence
The film's research found no reliable basis for the traditional 600 BC date beyond tradition and advises against stating it as fact. Specific scholarly ranges for the core text were identified as leads but not verified, so the site does not publish them. The English used in the film is Bhishagratna's translation, which witnesses the text but not its age.
Current standing
Disputed. The traditional date persists in popular histories. The film words the point cautiously: compiled over many centuries, its core perhaps two thousand years old, with tradition placing it earlier still.